Most in the football industry, let alone fans themselves, will find it hard to dispute that often once one club publicly courts/shows interest in a player it alerts other clubs to the player and a snowballing effect seems to occur.
Unfortunately, the problem is this desire to hear on the grapevine about other clubs and other scout' targets (even between scouts at one club) creates a situation which I term 'scouting with their ears, not their eyes'. I'd stand by the belief that 75% of scouts, particularly at youth level, are not keen to truly push a player forward until they hear another club is interested OR even if pushed, that club he/she scouts for won't actively pursue the player until they hear there is interest from other clubs...
This is the scouting with ears phenomenon of the industry.
Now I understand the theory from a Chief Scout or Academy Recruitment Director perspective, there are simply too many players and listening out to word of mouth is a good way of narrowing down who are the truly top players, likewise listening out could be simply 'intelligence gathering', however those in the industry will recognise that it is not often that sophisticated or planned to be that way. Often it simply does come to the fact that clubs are reactive to what other clubs are doing.
So from a fan's perspective or even a parent of a young player' perspective, if you ever look at a player in a team and think how have they had a chance to play for this team? It may well come down to the fact they may not have even been properly scouted and somewhere at some point there was a rush for the player because of scouts and clubs listening out for what's "hot" in the market from other clubs rather than identifying talent themselves and truly backing the scouts they utilize or getting rid of those scouts that do not have the eye but perhaps scout with their ears only.
No comments:
Post a Comment